Should I Do My Own SEO or Hire Someone? Weighing Pros and Cons

Deciding to undertake search engine optimization (SEO) for your website is a pivotal choice that can have a huge impact on your online presence and business success. It involves a set of strategies and techniques aimed at increasing the visibility of your website in search engine results pages. The decision whether to tackle this task on your own or to hire an SEO professional hinges on various factors, including your knowledge of SEO practices, the complexity of your website, available time, and budget.

If you opt to do your own SEO, it’s essential to first demystify the basics of SEO. While it can be complex, there are numerous resources available that can help you understand and implement fundamental SEO strategies. On the other hand, hiring an SEO specialist can provide expertise and ongoing support that is particularly beneficial for websites with a high level of competition or businesses aiming for fast and significant growth. Whichever path you choose, the goal is the same: to improve your site’s ranking, increase traffic, and enhance your online visibility.

Key Takeaways

  • Understanding the fundamentals of SEO is crucial for any approach.
  • DIY SEO is a feasible option with enough learning and time investment.
  • Professional SEO services offer expertise and save time but at a cost.

Understanding SEO Basics

YouTube video

In this section, we’ll explore the essentials of SEO, its key elements, and the analytical tools that are fundamental for anyone involved in optimizing websites.

Defining SEO and Its Importance

SEO, or Search Engine Optimization, is the practice of enhancing a website to improve its visibility when people search for products or services related to your business in Google and other search engines. A higher visibility in search results correlates to increased web traffic and potential for revenue growth.

SEO Components

The main components of SEO can be divided into three categories:

  1. On-Page SEO: This deals with optimizing individual web pages to rank higher. It includes elements like content, meta tags, and URL structure.
  2. Off-Page SEO: This refers to actions taken outside of your own site to impact your rankings within search engine results pages, such as backlinks and social signals.
  3. Technical SEO: Activities that improve the technical aspects of a site like site speed, mobile-friendliness, and structured data enhance the crawling and indexing phase for search engines.

Key SEO Tools and Analytics Platforms

To optimize effectively, we utilize various tools and platforms.

  • Google Analytics: A premier tool that helps in tracking user behavior, traffic sources, and a multitude of other data points on your website.
  • Google Search Console: An invaluable platform that provides insights into your website’s visibility on Google search results.
  • SEMrush: Offers competitive data for search engine rankings along with insights into SEO, content marketing, and advertising opportunities.
  • Screaming Frog: An indispensable tool for technical SEO audits, which helps us identify problems related to site crawling and indexing.

Through a thorough understanding of SEO basics and leveraging the right tools, we ensure that your website is not only found by search engines but also ranks well for relevant queries.

DIY SEO Versus Professional SEO Services

YouTube video

Embarking on the SEO journey can be daunting, but it’s essential to weigh the options between taking the reins yourself and bringing in an expert. Deciding whether to invest time in learning and implementing SEO strategies or to allocate funds for professional services can significantly impact your business’s online visibility and growth.

Pros and Cons of DIY SEO


  • Cost Savings: DIY SEO is primarily time-based. The only cost to us is our time. If operating on a tight budget, this can be particularly appealing.
  • Learning and Control: We acquire knowledge and maintain full control over our SEO strategies, enabling us to apply immediate changes to our website.


  • Time Commitment: SEO is not a set-and-forget task. It requires continual effort and staying current with the latest trends and algorithm changes, which can be very time-consuming.
  • Potential for Mistakes: Without ample experience, it’s easier to make costly mistakes. Missed opportunities and implementing bad SEO practices can negatively impact search rankings.

Benefits of Hiring an SEO Expert

Hiring an SEO expert, whether a freelancer or through an agency, presents us with the advantage of expertise and experience. These professionals stay up to date with the latest industry standards and can tailor strategies specifically for our business needs. They often bring:

  • Trust and Expertise: We rely on their knowledge to optimize our site correctly.
  • Time Efficiency: Delegating SEO allows us to focus on other areas of our business.

Evaluating SEO Service Costs

Cost of Services: When considering hiring an SEO professional, it’s important to look at the costs involved. SEO agencies typically offer various packages, from basic to comprehensive. We need to consider:

  • Budget: Does our budget allow for the costs of hiring an SEO expert?
  • Return on Investment: Investing in a professional can lead to better and quicker results, potentially offering a higher return on investment in the long term.

Deciding Between DIY and Outsourcing SEO

YouTube video

When we explore the realm of SEO for our business, we have to weigh the balance between internal capacities and the potential advantages of professional expertise.

Identifying Your SEO Goals and Resources

We need to have a clear understanding of what we want to achieve with our SEO efforts. Are we aiming to improve our rankings, attract more website visitors, or boost revenue? Knowing these goals is crucial in determining whether to invest in in-house SEO or outsource to a specialist. We must also assess our resources, including budget and time, to decide if we can afford an agency or if we should allocate funds to other aspects of our small business with more immediate growth potential.

Assessing In-House Skillsets

Do we have employees with on-page optimization skills who can effectively build links and manage technical SEO? If our team possesses a decent foundation in SEO, we might tackle the basics ourselves. However, SEO is complex and constantly changing, so we must consider if our in-house skills are advanced and up-to-date enough to compete in our industry.

When to Consider an SEO Agency or Freelancer

Should our in-house efforts not suffice or if the necessary time investment detracts from our core operations, it may be time to consider an SEO agency or freelancer. Outsourcing SEO to experts can ensure high-quality link building and nuanced strategy that our current team might not be equipped to handle. This option tends to be more suitable for us when we need specialized skills or when the scope of SEO work exceeds our team’s capacity, allowing us to focus on running our business.